Our Advisors Be an advisor FAQ Pricing Insights

The Value of Recent Experience in Navigating Today’s Admissions Landscape

If you had asked me two years ago whether I’d be helping other students apply to college, I probably would’ve laughed. At the time, I was neck-deep in personal statements, debating whether to go test-optional, and losing sleep over what extracurriculars truly "stood out." Fast forward to today—I’ve gotten into one of the most competitive universities in the country, and now I guide students just like I was not long ago. I’m what Pathways calls a peer advisor, and here’s the thing: when it comes to navigating today’s college admissions landscape, recency matters more than most people realize.

The College Admissions Game Has Changed—Fast

Let’s be honest. The rules of college admissions have shifted dramatically even in just the last 2–3 years. Test-optional policies, new FAFSA rollouts, evolving essay prompts, changing holistic review practices—it's a moving target. And traditional college counselors, even the really good ones, often don’t have a front-row seat to the latest nuances.

I lived through applying during COVID-era disruptions, the rise of test-blind schools, and trying to decipher how colleges were recalibrating GPA evaluations. I had to make decisions without precedent—do I still take the SAT even though my dream school doesn’t require it? Should I submit an optional video portfolio? How do I make up for a year of canceled volunteering?

Because I faced these exact dilemmas, I can give real, practical advice that’s grounded in firsthand experience.

Real Stories > Hypotheticals

A lot of students I work with tell me their school counselor gave them a checklist or a spreadsheet of deadlines. Helpful? Sure. But when you’re deciding whether to write your Common App personal statement about a deeply personal experience or a quirky passion, you don’t want theoretical frameworks. You want to hear from someone who actually wrote essays that worked—someone who’s been on both sides of the accept/reject line.

When I share my story about how I structured my “overcoming adversity” essay, or why I cut out two AP classes from my senior year to focus on research, students listen. Because it’s not just advice—it’s lived truth, tested in a real-world admissions gauntlet.

The Edge of Peer Advising

Working with a peer advisor means tapping into fresh, tactical insights that most traditional advising models don’t offer. For example:

  • I can show screenshots of my actual Common App and walk a student through what I picked and why.
  • I know which colleges changed their supplemental prompts last cycle and how students interpreted them.
  • I can explain how I balanced mental health with ambition—something that’s part of the student experience but often ignored by formal advisors.

This isn’t to knock professional counselors—they absolutely bring depth, structure, and years of perspective. But in today’s hyper-competitive, algorithm-driven, test-flexible landscape, you need someone who speaks both the strategy and the reality.

Keywords I Keep Hearing from Students

The students I coach keep bringing up terms like:

  • “How to get into competitive colleges”
  • “What makes a good college essay”
  • “Do I need SAT scores in 2025”
  • “College admissions advice from Ivy League students”
  • “What to write in the activities section”

I know the answers because I asked the same questions myself, not in theory, but in practice—and I figured them out.

Recent Experience Builds Trust

One of the most important parts of the college application journey is emotional support. When I tell a student, “Hey, I got deferred too, and here’s how I handled it,” their whole body language shifts. They know I get it. That empathy? It doesn’t come from textbooks or webinars. It comes from walking the path myself.

Final Thought

In a world where college admissions change faster than most people can keep up, having a peer advisor with recent experience isn’t just a nice-to-have. It’s a strategic advantage. I’m proud to be one of those voices for students—someone who’s walked through the fire and came out the other side, ready to guide the next group through it.