Applying as a Student-Athlete: Advice From Someone Who Lived It

By Jordan Matthews, Student-Athlete and College Freshman

I remember the day I decided I wanted to play basketball at the collegiate level. It wasn’t a sudden revelation. For years, I’d spent countless hours perfecting my game, dreaming about the day I’d be able to take my passion from high school courts to a college arena. But once I got serious about the application process, I quickly realized that being a student-athlete means balancing a lot more than just practice and games. It’s about managing your time, your priorities, and making sure you stand out both as an athlete and as a student.

I want to share my experience applying as a student-athlete because it’s not an easy road. Here’s what I wish I had known going into it.

Start Early — The Recruiting Process is a Marathon

One of the biggest lessons I learned was that recruiting isn’t something you can rush. I thought I could just focus on my game and hope for the best. But the reality is, coaches start looking at athletes as early as freshman year. The earlier you start, the better your chances.

When I started my junior year, I began reaching out to coaches. I emailed them my highlight reel, stats, and academic performance, and kept them updated on my progress. In hindsight, I wish I had started even earlier. Coaches are busy, and it’s a competitive process. They want to know you’re serious, not just about sports but also about your academics and character.

Balance is Everything — Don’t Neglect Your Studies

This was by far the hardest part for me. As a student-athlete, you can’t afford to let one area slip, whether it’s sports or your grades. But it’s easy to focus on athletics and assume your grades will take care of themselves.

For example, I remember my sophomore year, when basketball season was in full swing. I was exhausted after practice and games, and my math homework started piling up. The temptation to skip assignments and cram before exams was huge, but I learned quickly that neglecting my studies wasn’t an option. The colleges I was targeting had academic standards that were just as demanding as the athletic ones.

In fact, a coach may want you on their team, but if your grades aren’t up to par, you won’t get in. So I learned to manage my time by creating a schedule where I dedicated specific blocks of time for schoolwork and sports. I didn’t always get it right, but the discipline helped me stay on track.

The Personal Statement: Show Them Who You Are

When I started writing my personal statement for college applications, I thought it would be all about basketball — my skills, achievements, and what I could bring to the team. But when I started drafting, I realized something important: the personal statement is your chance to show the admissions team who you are beyond your athletic abilities.

I wrote about how basketball had shaped me, yes, but also how it had taught me about resilience, teamwork, leadership, and time management. I spoke about challenges I’d overcome, both on and off the court, and how those experiences had shaped my character. It wasn’t just about basketball; it was about how the sport had influenced my life in meaningful ways.

I also talked about how I planned to balance my athletic commitments with academic pursuits. Being a student-athlete isn’t just about playing a sport — it’s about managing multiple responsibilities, and that’s a huge part of who I am as a person. In the end, I believe that’s what made my application stand out.

Be Realistic About What You Can Handle

I won’t sugarcoat it: applying as a student-athlete is tough. You’re balancing recruitment calls, applying to schools, and dealing with the emotional rollercoaster of waiting for responses. But you also have to be realistic about what you can handle, both in terms of academics and sports. I had to be honest with myself about which schools were a good fit, both academically and athletically.

As much as I wanted to play Division I basketball, I knew that the commitment would be intense, and I wasn’t sure I could juggle that with my academic goals. So I looked at Division II and III schools, which still offered great athletic programs, but with a more balanced approach to student life. This was one of the best decisions I made, as it allowed me to compete at a high level while also thriving in my studies.

Expect the Unexpected — And Be Ready to Adapt

Finally, the most important thing I learned in the process was to be flexible. The recruitment process, the admissions process, and the transition to college can all throw curveballs your way. I thought I had everything planned out, but I had to adapt when my first-choice school didn’t offer me a spot on the team. Instead of getting discouraged, I focused on my next best option and embraced it with the same passion.

At the end of the day, your path might not look exactly as you envisioned, but that doesn’t mean it won’t be the right path for you. Keep working hard, stay focused on your goals, and remember that being a student-athlete is about more than just playing a sport. It’s about managing time, building resilience, and growing as an individual. You’ll learn a lot about yourself along the way.

Take the Leap

If you’re a student-athlete thinking about college applications, take a deep breath and start early. The process may feel overwhelming, but it’s an incredible opportunity to shape your future. And remember: don’t just focus on being a great athlete, focus on being a great student, leader, and person. Those qualities will get you further than you might think.

Find a peer advisor at Pathways, our community has someone who is just like you, has done it and can walk you through the process.